MAIN MENU
Reviewer Guidelines
Responsibility of Peer Reviewer
Peer reviewer not only responsible for reading and evaluating to critiquing manuscripts in the field of expertise, but also giving honest feedback and constructive advice to the author. Peer reviewers, evaluate the strengths, quality, relevancy, and authenticity of the manuscript of the article.
Before reviewing, please note the following:
- The article that requested to be reviewed must congruence with your expertise.
- The review process must be done within 2 (two) weeks.
- Have no conflict of interest with the author or the article.
Review Process
When reviewing the article, please consider the following:
- Title: must clearly illustrating the article.
- Abstract: must reflect the contents of the article.
- Introduction: must describe the accuracy of matters submitted by the author and clearly state the problem being considered, also should explain the experiments, hypotheses, and methods. Typically, the introduction should summarize the context of the relevant research, and explain the findings of the research or other findings, if any, offered for discussion.
Content of the Article
- Must pass plagiarism check.
- Must fairly new, deep, and interesting to be published.
- Should have contribution to knowledge.
- Must adhere to the standards of the journal
- Must in line with the objectives and scope of the journal.
Method
Comprehensive and perfect:
- Accurately describe how the data is collected.
- Theoretical basis or reference used appropriately.
- The exposure design suitable for the answer to the question.
- Having a decent enough information for you to imitate the research.
- Havinh detail explanation for new method.
- Having appropriate sampling.
- Having adequately explanation for tools and materials used.
- Having description for type of data and measurement
Results:
The explaination of the findings should be clearly laid out and in a logical sequence. You will need to consider whether the appropriate analysis has been carried out; the use of statistical tools? If you have a better statistical tools to be used in this study, notify it, and the interpretation need not to be included in this section.
Discussion and Conclusion:
- the claims in this section is supported by the fair results and quite reasonable
- the author compare the research results with other previous ones
- the conclusion explain how a better scientific research to be followed-up
Tables and Pictures:
Suitable with the referred explanation by showing data which is easy to to interprete and understanable for the readers.
Writing Styles
- Authors must be critical mostly to the literature systematic review of the issues, which is relevant to the field of study.
- Reviews should be focused on a single topic.
- All exposure should be in English and written in a god and coherent grammar.
- Easy to understand
- Interesting to read
Things that need to be considered:
- Perspective, a unique perspective that describes experiences and situations related to issues in marketing management, finance management, strategic management, operation management, human resource management, e-business, knowledge management, management accounting, management control system, management information system, international business, business economics, business ethics and suistainable, and entrepreneurship.
Originality Research
- The original data and testing, it must present data that offers a new approach to improve systems, processes, and precision of the tools which are used.
- Research policy and observational analysis, it should clarify the feasibility, effectiveness, and implementation on the research results. It is not limited to the topic of marketing management, finance management, strategic management, operation management, human resource management, e-business, knowledge management, management accounting, management control system, management information system, international business, business economics, business ethics and suistainable, and entrepreneurship.
- In Practice (case study), The paper should explain the situation regarding the future challenges in marketing management, finance management, strategic management, operation management, human resource management, e-business, knowledge management, management accounting, management control system, management information system, international business, business economics, business ethics and suistainable, and entrepreneurship, within its conclusions, and things which can be learned.
Reference
- First Person (Interview)
- Book Reviews
- Insight Technology (Product Review)
Final Review
- All results of the review submitted by reviewers are confidential
- If you want to discuss the article with a colleague, kindly inform the editor
- Do not contact the author directly.
- Ethical issues:
- Plagiarism: if you suspect the article is mostly plagiarism from other authors, please let the editor knows the details
- Fraud: It is very difficult to detect a fraud catogory, but if you suspect the results in the article is not true, please inform the editor
- When you write a comment, please show the part of the comment that is only intended for the editor and parts that can be returned to the author.
Please do not hesitate to contact the editorial office with any questions or problems that you may encounter.
